"If you prick us, do we not bleed?" asks Shakespeare's Shylock in The Merchant of Venice.
I just listened to an intriguing presentation by Andrew Gordon, a scholar of Jewish American literature at University of Florida, called "The Jew as Vampire: Bernard Malamud's 'The Fixer.'" In it, he examines Jews as vital scapegoats in general and in the context of Malamud's work. Of particular interest, are some of his comments on the history of the blood libel legend, which always involves the sacrifice of a child.
The first explanation for the proliferation of this legend is something called "projective inversion," which he actually quotes from another scholar, and which I find fascinating in a very creepy sort of way. According to this explanation, it is the Christians' own guilt — for turning their god into a sacrifice, and then proceeding to drink his blood and eat his flesh during communion rituals — that is projected onto the Jewish scapegoat.
The second has more to do with the tendency of older siblings to resent, and want to kill, their younger siblings (though this doesn't make complete sense to me since it seems more reasonable that the Jews would represent the older sibling, and the Christians the younger, but whatever). We also see this in the blibical story of Joseph and his brothers — and it seems relevant to me to point out, also, that in the Hebrew bible younger brothers ALWAYS prevail, or are more special (Isaac, Jacob, Joseph and Benjamin, etc).
I think both of these explanations are interesting for various reasons. I mean, think about it — does it really make sense that Jews, who culturally and religiously shun blood (kosher meat, no intercourse during a woman's menstrual cycle, etc), would be the brunt of such an accusation? Of course it doesn't help that in the gospel of Matthew we are told that "his blood" will be upon us and our children and our children's children. But I think this first explanation does much to untangle the bizarre web of Christians' obsession with Jews and blood.
At any rate, it's always frustrating to try to get to the root of such anti-Semitic legends. As one scholar pointed out today: Whenever you have a biblically-based culture, there you'll have anti-Semitism. In this sense, it is impossible to find one Jew who does not, in the words of Art Spiegelman, "bleed history."
Thanks for taking the time to line this all out for people like us. This post was very useful in my opinion.
Thank you spending some time to talk about the following, I’m boldy a lot and even true love studying more to do with now this topic. However, if future, when you realize know-how, do you ever thoughts bringing up-to-date all your webpage that have a lot more stuff? This is useful for my family.
I rattling pleased to find this site on bing, just what I was looking for : D too bookmarked .
This site is actually amazing. We constantly run into something new & diverse correct right here. Appreciate which data.
Hey, I’ve been ranking the crap out of “pre spun articles”.
you have got a excellent weblog here! want to develop invite posts on my weblog?
Great write-up, I am normal visitor of one’s website, maintain up the nice operate, and It is going to be a regular visitor for a long time.