Now Reading
Deliver Us From AIPAC
The Divorce Dress
Yom Kippur: From the Horniest Holiday to the Holiest
Get Jewcy in your inbox!
It’s Parshonal: Vayeilech and Learning to Let Go

Deliver Us From AIPAC

In an interview with Press TV on January 24 , Noam Chomsky gave voice to the cynicism of the hardcore left, predicting that the Obama administration would show little substantive difference with past American governments in its dealings with Israel.

"The US is not going to join the world in seeking to implement a diplomatic settlement," Chomsky told his Iranian interlocutor. "and if that is the case, (George) Mitchell’s mission is vacuous."

In theory, one can debate all sorts of things. However, the proof is in the actions oft he new president. Already we are seeing signs that Chomsky’s pessimism is misplaced. In fact, early indications show a distinct change in American policy, with the possibility of more to come.

Durban 2

One small examplewas Obama’s reversal of the Bush administration’sdecision to boycott the planning of the so-called Durban2 conference. This gathering, which will be held in Geneva in April, is a follow up to the much criticized first World Conference Against Racism that took place in 2001 in Durban, SouthAfrica.

That conference was largely diverted by pro-Palestinian groups and governments pushing anextremist agenda. The US and Israel both walked out. Some of those same NGOs and governmental delegations are pushing a similar agenda this time. But there are also strong forces working to ensure that this WCAR addresses broader issues of racism, and avoids the descenti nto anti-Semitism that characterized the first conference.

Israel has already announced its boycott, as has Canada. The United States has now decided, however, that the best way to prevent the conference from descending into an anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic frenzy is to engage in the event’s planning. If that fails, the Americans can always decide not to participate, as the U.S. and Israeli delegations did in 2001.

Barack Obama should be applauded for taking this course of action. He is working to prevent another demonstration of anti-Jewish racism, while demonstrating that failed strategies for combating it are being abandoned. Sadly, the Israeli government, and a number of prominent U.S. Jewish leaders would rather continue to use claims of anti-Semitism as a political hammer than try to eradicate the phenomenon.

The Settlements

The Durban 2 decision is nothing in comparison to the stance that is emerging regarding settlement expansion in the West Bank. Ha’aretz reported on February 15 that Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and Special Mideast Envoy George Mitchell are expected to take a firm stance with Israel on settlement expansion, including threatening to reduce the remaining $1.3 billion in loan guarantees the US has promised to Israel by the amount spent on settlement expansion.

This expectation was bolstered by statements in the House of Representatives Subcommittee on the Middle East and South Asia. On February 12, opening a hearing on the Gaza War, the chairman of the subcommittee, Gary Ackerman, one of the House’s key pro-Israel leaders, issued a scathing indictment of Israel’s settlement enterprise. Coming from a source like Ackerman, blame for the stalled peace process being laid at the doorstep of settlements alongside (though not, Ackerman was quick to point out, on an equal footing with) Palestinian violence was surprising, to say the least.

Ackerman’s bold statement indicates that the direction Obama intends to head in is being mapped out not only with his own team of advisors, but with key pro-Israel figures in Congress. Unlike Jimmy Carter or George H.W. Bush, whose maverick policy making endeavors eschewed such collaboration, Obama is crafting an approach that he hopes will be executed without opposition from legislators and AIPAC-allied forces.

Indeed, at that very hearing (which I attended) we saw how things may split amongst Israel’s supporters in Congress. While Shelly Berkley and ranking Republican Dan Burton sang the same old tune, other notable figures like Robert Wexler appeared very much in line with Ackerman, as did some of the House’s newer lawmakers, such asrepresentatives Gerald Connolly and Michael McMahon. This indicates that the Obama team has marshaled reasonable Democrats behind it, and is ready to brave the attacks of the old guard.

Border Crossings

It is no coincidence that Israel has suddenly shown a willingness to discuss ways to openGaza’s border crossings as part of a long-term truce and reconstruction arrangement. The idea was never hinted at during the Bush administration’s tenure, right through its very last day. Suddenly, under Obama, it has become a cornerstone of every proposed arrangement.

In my discussions with officials at the State Department, it has been very clear that, while they always felt this was a necessary condition, Israel’s responsiveness to the idea changed dramatically once they knew the President agreed with that direction.

Obama’s team has demonstrated its interest in building stability in Gaza. It has also been absolutely clear (as was Ackerman) that anything that legitimized Hamas was a red line it was not willing to cross. But  instead of leaving the people of Gaza to starve, they have insisted on exploring alternatives that would allow the territory’s civilian population to pursue their businesses and access needed services while bypassing its Islamist government

This strategy might well fail. The hope is to find a way to re-establish the Palestinian Authority in Gaza. Hamas is both determined and well-positioned enough to prevent that. The Obama administration will not legitimize Hamas, and sees that as too high a price to pay to open up access to the devastated territory.

Hamas stands accused of very serious breaches of Gazans’ trust. It appears to have wantonly deployed its forces in civilian areas during the fighting with Israel (to a greater degree than the considerable extent that the physical terrain and crowded conditions of Gaza made inevitable), and it has carried out beatings and executions of political enemies during and after the war. Hamas’ well-documented attempts to steal aid from UNRWA nearly cut off the one lifeline for humanitarian assistance that the people of Gaza have left.

Hamas’ position is not strong, and recent polls indicate that, while its profile remains high in the Arab world at large, in Gaza, support is at a low point. There may indeed be a way to administer the crossings without benefiting the Palestinian organization.

However, even if there is not, the fact that the US has chosen to vigorously pursue this approach is further evidence of real change from the Obama administration. Its stated eagerness to open a dialogue with Syria, and its slow pace in appointing an envoy to Iran further underline the depth of this change.

The Blank Cheque Has Bounced

Despite this change in policy direction, it is important to recognize that Israel isstill the American government’s most valued ally in the Middle East. It is seen by the Obama administration as the closest friend the US has in the region, and it will remain that way on the President’s final day in office.

What has taken hold in Washington is the clarity that only a party outside of a conflict can have. It is the view of what is truly in the best interest of both Israel and America. It is an understanding that giving Israel a blank cheque to decide its own course is unwise, especially when that course is subject to the volatile emotions of a populace in long-term conflict and a political system that is fractured and broken.

Martin Indyk, former US ambassador to Israel and founder ofthe pro-Israel think tank the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, stated after Obama’s electoral victory that the "era of the blank cheque is over." This change is not due to decreased sympathy for Israel. On the contrary, it is precisely because of such sentiments, combined with a sober analysis of Israeli needs, that the Obama administration is embarking on this course. And it’s also why it may very well succeed.

The rightward shift in Israel is a major obstacle. But Israel — even Benjamin Netanyahu– has already demonstrated that it understands that this is a new America it’s dealing with. The question of how effective this strategy will be will come down to how well the Obama administration can deal with the backlash from so-called "pro-Israel" forces, who do not understand how much harm they are doing to the Jewish state, with their focus on protecting the settlements and defending other Israeli policy excesses.

Part of that equation will be measured by Obama’s willingness to stay the course. But part will also come from the efforts of pro-Israel, pro-peace groups whose task it will be to counter two opposing forces. One is the supporters of the status quo, such as AIPAC, and more radical US organizations, such as the Zionist Organization of America. The other is the radical left who will follow Chomsky’s lead and insist that until the US adopts an unrealistic and ineffective posture of withdrawing its support (particularly military aid) for Israel, nothing will change.

Moderate US peace organizations must demonstrate that a clear American stance that supports Israel’s ability to defend itself, insists on an end to the settlement enterprise, and that gives Palestinians a real chance to build their society is a politically viable and effective position. Though liberal activists and pundits alike have been making this point for years, this is the first time since the beginning of the Oslo era where there has been such a serious chance to actually follow through. If they are effective, Obama’s diplomacy stands a serious chance of succeeding.

View Comments (2)
  • am i going to express stuff the actual BBC

    gain the benefits of giving out control keys

    particular web sites around the BBC have a button that lets you a check out that page. the following a wonderful way of revealing to neighbors [url=] review[/url] all-around something advantageous. click on the express icon and you will see here are the software program as squidoo, Google+ quite possibly facebook.

    our staff members specific the ones which are most fashionable with people who use the BBC. on the an BBC url pages, twitter will be more dominant whilst they typically the most popular. all of the giving treatment people around the globe check out may be at no cost.

    in the event you portion to your social media software ones key phrases ought to employ. publish check out certain the way (Which searching for on the web).

    add our player on your blog post nor social multimedia system

    barely add how the participant is effective

    look at site content from the jawhorse

    introduce any sort of happy why doesn offer an press button.

    write-up observations as sees about today’s shareables

    provided they not likely malefic.

    getting small in jeopardy

    a whole lot bootleg. like for example choosing never enjoy language, Inciting terror toism draining solitude law

    any scenario that would injured a person’s BBC distinction.

    put on assist shareables represent they are not free

    on the phone to charge up other sites for utilizing my shareables. If you put them on a niche site it cost, announce it liberated to view.

    don cause them to become additional notable when non BBC video

    more this seem as if experts endorsing person. then have on make something of the filled with a mere our shareables.

    add exaggerate all of your marital life with this BBC

    wear utter our company market, market, generate while well as approve individuals. put on start using shareables regarding politics uses. and consequently have on if you have excellent authority to access our reports.

  • Throughout that guide he supplied his results about the actual massive variations that happen to be discovered regarding the genders, very by means of your entire strategies they appear into in order to deliver up in order to the other. 1 grownup relationship guidance you need to use will be to assist make your account clever and enticing in order to talked about. Tip Number3: Make an effort to be Natural: Conference anyone from your on-set sightless online dating initially will make you truly feel annoyed and scared. You’ll need to study and use some adult courting pointers for internet dating on the web or maybe in books. Tip Number4: End your Specific date having a Compliment: A fantastic technique of parting utilizing your on-line sightless on-line relationship spouse along with your initially day is definitely by admiring his campaigns making the day nice and certainly one of a form for each of you.

    You’re the one who chooses of which you wish to interact with. Lots of people who are married immediately confess they really employed the following pointers in circumstantial variables to secure his or her current spouses, and if it truely does work with such assured success for some individuals, it will almost definitely work with you. The next few paragraphs will now explain numerous online courting security suggestions that may serve in stopping deceitful males and females participated in online dating. As a substitute of studying all how-to ideas or alternatively [url=]how to tell if a vietnamese woman likes you[/url] desirous to know an extremely best ally for her recommendation, wouldn’t anyone including to be able to find out what men them certainly assume? As if you mosey, participate in lawn practicing tennis, try automotive bike racing or go to the health and fitness heart. Visit metropolis websites, look over photographs, engage your self in numerous travel boards, where yow will discover helpful recommendation from frequent travelers. If you are doubting about it, take a map, tick the places you have got already been and contour those which you’d want to go to. Setting guidelines in your appointments permits you to make the most of the day in an exceedingly mild way and familiarize your self with your day better.

    If that’s so, your not establishing a suitable worthy of by yourself house for being person. In Conclusion, they’re 3 critical courting recommendation males of all ages which can definitely produce a large distinction in your life so lengthy as you actually positioned them to work: get on-line, get a everyday residing with one another and establish an immense societal worthy of on all by yourself. The child birds are searhing for adult men of all ages which are articles and linked with due to their profession, or preserve their own well being along with a respectable level of financial trustworthiness. The obtainable Boomer Woman, is very afraid advertising little or no for me personally that sherrrd like so as to satisfy grownup men. In order for you a sports and dynamic gentleman – replicate on your own you are into athletics and a few measures. Do you have to choose a gentleman who’s going to be in monetary phrases firm, the top grownup courting guidance in your case is comprehend stocks and shares so as to focus on it with him. In closing, your dating personal is essential as a result of it could actually offer you the chance to fulfill extra people. Along with the whole lot that the primary motels in Cancun offer you (particularly the all-inclusive ones), town provides many more choices.

    In the event you miss this step, you won’t be able to unveil all the historical past and mystery hidden in the city walls. Suppose about quite a few many of those options from Greyish as well as different relationship execs who happen to be men: Think about the best way in which guys maintain score. Go forward and apply the over on web web page Web optimization suggestions on your funding site and see the outcomes for on your own. Most people endeavor to take care of lengthy-time period associations with others, however, over time we both lose enthusiasm and even sabotage a majority of those relationships. Community might probably giggle at her that in her superior age group – 50 and over. A neighborhood factor which occurs to be utilized by single women and men right at this second is social networks along with on-line dating sites. The single Relationship Manual made it viable ought to just try this! You precept Off white and maybe many people have thought of usually could be the real varied methods all by means of which people Inchmaintain scoreInch pertaining to a romantic relationship. I’ve look at quite a few profiles which may have sentences like, “no sport titles – I’ve had satisfactory involving them,” and even “damaged coronary heart needs healed.” This kind of factors smacks of emotive baggage – something very toddler explicit desires to find a intimate romantic relationship dealing with cope with.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll To Top